La Defense district, Paris

In March 1982, the French President announced a vast operation of town-planning and architectural projects, including the “Tête Defense” competition. 

This competition was organised by the Établissement public pour l’aménagement de La Défense. 

It was sponsored by the International Union of Architectes (UIA). This international competition was conducted in one stage and maintained the anonymity of all participants. 

 

Competition results

Winning Prize

Theme and objectives

This competition was part of an ambitious architectural policy aimed at providing future generations with outstanding testimonials of present day society. It was a groundbreaking policy that reflected one of the major preoccupations of the time: communications. 

The plan for La Défense finally took shape in the 1950s with the takeoff of metropolitan economic expansion and urban migration. The Établissement public pour l’aménagement de La Défense (EPAD) was created in 1958 to develop a business district that would prolong and complete the line of monuments extending westward from the Palace of the Tuileries with a new motorway. 

In September 1981, the new government decided to take on and complete the previously abandoned “Tête Défense” scheme on the basis of a more ambitious and significant programme. 

Such a decision was based on a political programme which aimed to promote France as a country with a culture of universal appeal carrying a message of freedom and international solidarity amid the economic, technological and cultural changes occurring in the 20th century. 

The scheme had two main types of programmes. One asserted the presence of the State in a new area of the capital through the construction of two ministries. The other, tied to President Mitterand’s international communication project  (C.I.C.O.M), marked the cultural expansion of a business area and rounded off Paris’ international vocation. 

The scheme had to be implemented on an area of 5,5 hectares and offer a useable floor space of about 120,000 sq.m (37,000 sq.m for C.I.C.O.M, 23,000 sq.m for associated organisations, 54,000 sq.m for the new ministries and 8,000 sq.m for services and shops). 


Key criteria

The following criteria were taken into account during the assessment of competition entries: 

  • Perception of the building: 
  • Integration with the urban fabric and architecture of the district of La Défense;
  • Symbolic value of the whole group of buildings;
  • Monumentality from the following points of view: visual impact of the district from a distance and from other Parisian monuments along the east-west line, its proportions;
  • Dynamic perception: approach to and discovery of the building, particularly from the roads to the west of Paris;
  • Close perception: shapes, external materials, visibility of each programme component;
  • Nighttime aspect.
  • Links with adjacent sites: 
  • Visibility and ease of use of the various access points;
  • Links between the buildings and their immediate environment;
  • Treatment of surrounding areas. 
  • Adherence to the programme: 
  • Functional organisation: provisions for principal activities and access points;
  • Use of allocated land;
  • Ratio of gross floorspace to useable floorspace;
  • Quality of spaces: layout and organisation of internal spaces and connections in order to encourage the creation of pleasant, lively destinations for meetings and exchanges of ideas/experiences. 
  • Feasibility: 
  • The technical and economic feasibility of the scheme: consideration of the constraints on foundations and implementation, implications of the overall design project on operation costs and energy efficiency.

Jury Members

  • Robert Lion, President of the Jury, Senior government official, FRANCE;
  • Mhadi El Mandjra, Senior government official, Vice-President, MOROCCO;
  • Richard Meier, Architect and Vice-President, USA;
  • Gérard Thurnauer, Architect and Secretary, FRANCE;
  • Serge Antoine, Senior government official, FRANCE; 
  • Oriol Bohigas, Architect, SPAIN; 
  • Jorge Glusberg, Art critic, ARGENTINA; 
  • Antoine Grumbach, Architect, FRANCE;
  • Ada Louise Huxtable, Architectural critic, USA;
  • Kisho Kurokawa, Architect, JAPAN; 
  • Louis Moissonnier, Senior government official, FRANCE; 
  • Richard Rogers, Architect, ENGLAND;
  • Bernard Zehrfuss, Architect, FRANCE.


Results

Competition closed. Results announced on May 1983

COMPETITION RESULTS

Reference documents